1. Home
  2. Blog
  3. How to Do SEO for My Website: Why Everything You’ve Heard About SEO is Wrong

How to Do SEO for My Website: Why Everything You’ve Heard About SEO is Wrong

If you’re a startup owner planning to DIY SEO for your business website, you’ve probably been bombarded with advice about on-page optimization and endless keyword strategies. But here’s the truth: focusing solely on on-page SEO won’t get you the results you want.The real game-changer? Off-page SEO. And no, it’s not just about building backlinks — it’s about building your website’s authority, reputation, and trust across the digital landscape. Let’s flip the script and dive into the strategies that will actually move the needle.

Why Off-Page SEO Deserves Your Attention

Everyone talks about on-page SEO, but if you’re ignoring off-page SEO, you’re leaving money on the table. Off-page SEO signals to search engines that your website isn’t just well-optimized internally — it’s trusted and valued by others across the web.So how do you build that trust and authority? Not by spamming links or obsessing over keywords. Instead, focus on these counterintuitive strategies.

1. Stop Chasing Backlinks — Start Earning Them

You’ve been told backlinks are everything. That’s only half true. What matters isn’t the number of backlinks — it’s the quality and context of those links.Here’s how to earn high-quality backlinks the right way:

  • Create Content People Actually Want to Share: Data-driven reports, unique insights, and actionable guides get linked naturally.
  • Guest Blogging Done Right: Don’t just write for any blog. Target authoritative sites in your niche.
  • Strategic Networking: Build genuine relationships with industry leaders. Real connections lead to real mentions.
  • Influencer Partnerships: Collaborate with influencers who align with your brand and values.

Case Study: A SaaS startup once published a comprehensive industry report filled with unique data. By promoting it through outreach and social sharing, they earned backlinks from high-authority sites like TechCrunch and HubSpot. This single piece of content generated hundreds of quality backlinks and a massive boost in search rankings.It’s not a numbers game. A few quality links from trusted sources will always outweigh hundreds of low-quality backlinks.

2. Social Media Isn’t Just for Likes — It’s for Authority

Most businesses treat social media as a megaphone. Stop doing that.Instead, use social platforms to build your website’s credibility:

  • Engage in Meaningful Conversations: Comment on relevant posts, answer questions, and provide value.
  • Share Content That Educates and Inspires: When people find your content valuable, they’ll share it — and those social signals boost your visibility.
  • Leverage LinkedIn for B2B Authority: Thought leadership posts and industry discussions can drive high-quality traffic and mentions.

Example: A productivity software startup began sharing detailed, actionable tips on LinkedIn. Their engagement skyrocketed, and industry leaders started sharing their posts. This not only increased their reach but also earned valuable backlinks from blogs referencing their insights.Social proof matters. A strong social presence tells search engines you’re a brand worth paying attention to.

3. Ditch Generic Directories — Go Local and Niche

Submitting your site to every directory under the sun won’t help you rank. Instead, focus on:

  • Local Listings: Google My Business, Yelp, and local business directories boost local SEO.
  • Industry-Specific Directories: If you’re in SaaS, healthcare, or retail, find directories your audience actually uses.
  • Consistency in NAP: Ensure your business name, address, and phone number are identical across every listing.

4. Influencer Marketing Isn’t Optional

Think influencer marketing is just for product-based businesses? Think again.When industry experts share your content or mention your brand, it’s a powerful trust signal. But if you’re a small business with a limited budget, you don’t need to chase big-name influencers. Here’s how to do it without breaking the bank:

  • Identify Micro-Influencers: They often have higher engagement and more niche authority — and they’re more affordable.
  • Offer Value: Share their content, engage with their posts, and build relationships before asking for anything.
  • Barter Services: If you offer a service they need, propose a collaboration in exchange for exposure.
  • Create Collaborative Content: Co-author articles, do interviews, or host joint webinars — all without hefty fees.
  • Gift Products or Free Trials: If you have a product or service, offer it for free in exchange for an honest review or mention.

Budget-Friendly Tactic: A small design agency offered free website audits to niche micro-influencers in exchange for shoutouts. This led to high-quality referrals and backlinks from their followers.Influencer marketing doesn’t have to drain your budget. With a strategic approach, you can build authentic partnerships that drive real results.

5. Outreach Isn’t Spam — It’s Strategy

Forget those mass email templates asking for backlinks. Smart outreach is about offering real value.

  • Pitch Unique Angles: If you’ve created original research or unique insights, pitch them to journalists and bloggers.
  • Offer Expert Commentary: Help reporters with their stories via platforms like HARO (Help a Reporter Out).
  • Collaborate, Don’t Beg: Propose content collaborations or expert roundups that benefit both parties.

6. Brand Mentions Matter More Than Links

Yes, backlinks are important — but so are unlinked brand mentions.When your brand gets mentioned in trusted publications, search engines take notice. Build your online PR game by:

  • Building Media Relationships: Connect with journalists and bloggers in your industry.
  • Positioning Yourself as an Expert: Offer insights and expert takes on industry trends.
  • Securing Podcast and Webinar Spots: These interviews often lead to brand mentions and links.

7. Skip the Spammy Bookmarking — Go Where Your Audience Hangs Out

Reddit, Quora, and niche forums drive real engagement — if you do it right.

  • Add Value First: Answer questions thoughtfully and share insights without spamming links.
  • Share Content Sparingly: Only post your content when it’s directly relevant to the conversation.
  • Become a Trusted Voice: Consistency and value will naturally drive traffic and mentions.

Example: A small business offering productivity software started engaging on Quora by providing detailed, helpful answers about workflow optimization. Over time, their answers gained traction, earning thousands of views and driving a steady stream of highly qualified traffic to their website. This approach not only boosted visibility but also led to organic backlinks from people referencing their insights.

8. Your Online Reputation Is SEO Gold

Think your reviews don’t impact SEO? Think again.

  • Monitor Mentions: Use tools like Google Alerts to track what’s being said about your brand.
  • Respond Quickly and Professionally: How you handle feedback shapes your reputation.
  • Encourage Positive Reviews: Happy customers rarely leave reviews unless you ask.

A strong online reputation tells search engines you’re a trustworthy business worth ranking.

The Bottom Line: SEO Is About Trust, Not Tricks

The Bottom Line: SEO Is About Trust, Not Tricks Stop over-optimizing your on-page elements and start building real authority off the page. Search engines reward brands people trust — and that trust comes from valuable content, authentic connections, and a stellar reputation. Ready to take your SEO game to the next level?Let’s build something remarkable. Start today with this quick-start SEO checklist tailored for DIY startup owners:

  • Identify and prioritize high-quality backlink opportunities.
  • Engage meaningfully on forums like Reddit and Quora.
  • Build relationships with micro-influencers and industry experts.
  • Ensure consistency across local and niche directory listings.
  • Monitor and manage your online reputation actively.

Don’t wait — pick one strategy from this list, take action today, and set your business up for long-term growth and visibility! 

🚀Need expert guidance to supercharge your SEO efforts? Get in touch with Agile Digital Marketing — your partner in building a powerful, scalable online presence.